◇ 《牽阮的手》批踢踢movie板文章整理 (至11/29)

 院線上映前                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         kinple
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_7384.html


 2011.11.18                                           ◥◣◥



 2011.11.19                                           ◥◣◥

[  雷] 牽起年輕世代的手「牽阮的手」                     asity
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_2050.html


 2011.11.20                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 《牽阮的手》：故事從愛開始                       ryuichiru
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_9655.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手：浪漫主義者的愛與理想                   KamaSutra 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_7596.html


 2011.11.21                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 《牽阮的手》by（時光之硯）                       NEKObus
http://blog.yam.com/YenC/article/44421739

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         a36958
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_2548.html

[好雷] 《牽阮的手》─在悲情之外的民主運動史             imaydayaa123
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_7981.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         kurtgod 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_6366.html

[好雷] 推薦《牽阮的手》                                 DropOut 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_3203.html

[悲雷] 牽阮的手                                         djviva 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_2911.html

[好雷] 看過賽德克後，一定要看牽阮的手                   Epismo 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_9767.html


 2011.11.22                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 《牽阮的手》─為何而哭？                         BlueStyle
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_605.html


 2011.11.23                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         visionwind
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_6174.html

[好雷] 《牽阮的手》                                     hg7318480 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_6013.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手   (內有些微劇情雷)                      qazpo 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_9808.html

Re: [好雷] 牽阮的手                                     fansss 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/re_1573.html


 2011.11.24                                           ◥◣◥

Re: [好雷] 牽阮的手                                     bkebke
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/re_9288.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         goplayer
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_515.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         paraclub
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_4850.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手-很多人不敢面對的片                      PttJoke 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_3636.html

[ 好雷] <牽阮的手>                                      gingi 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_8307.html


 2011.11.25                                           ◥◣◥

[雷] 牽阮的手                                           eslite12
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_2178.html


 2011.11.26                                           ◥◣◥

[普雷] 牽阮的手                                         zoeblue
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_402.html


 2011.11.27                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         im30cm
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_845.html

[微雷] 支持賽德克的理由也可用在《牽阮的手》             NewSean
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_4718.html


 2011.11.28                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 牽阮的手--站在歷史前的謙卑                       dennyjason
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_29.html

[普雷] 牽阮的手                                         gray43
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_7972.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         flyingburger
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_4804.html


 2011.11.29                                           ◥◣◥

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         sherry613
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_7584.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手                                         toaster
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_4435.html

[好雷] 牽阮的手 - 媽的這種好片居然快下檔了              subaru 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_3027.html

Re: [普雷] 牽阮的手                                     eslite12 
http://bbscollectiton.blogspot.com/2011/11/re_9736.html





＊以上文章皆轉載自批踢踢movie版



　

【推文至plurk】

表演藝術評論台—《夢想家》評論專題

 作者  pessoa0926 (sp2008)                                        看板  Drama 
 標題  表演藝術評論台—《夢想家》評論專題                                     
 時間  Thu Oct 13 09:55:47 2011                                               

! 建國百年大製作，以上億規模製作《夢想家》，這不僅是齣國人自製音樂劇，
從藝術面向有許多值得關注的事項；更因為將歷史融入戲劇，以中華民國史
為命題，其所觸及史觀與歷史觀照，更是藝術家不能迴避的核心價值。
《夢想家》實踐了哪些藝術夢想？為國人帶來什麼文創音樂劇願景？
如何詮釋歷史？如何創造一處夢想與現實兼具的表演舞台？
表演藝術評論台製作企畫焦點【夢想，何以為家？】，邀請藝評人撰文評析，
也歡迎大家以投稿，留言，短評等形式加入討論，一同檢視夢想與實踐的距離！

評論文之ㄧ
有政治沒藝術，有中華民國沒台灣《夢想家》
這齣戲竟也跟建國百年的眾多燒錢大製作一樣，淪陷得如此難堪。
我只希望民國100年趕快過去，慶典趕快結束，讓藝術的歸藝術，
政治的歸政治。這樣藝術家才有機會做出有尊嚴的作品，給政治家學習。(鴻鴻）
全文連結 http://pareviews.ncafroc.org.tw/?p=776
評論文之二
形式空洞，夢想如何實踐《夢想家》
戲中的清官，說著一口京腔、全身如同京劇演員的打扮，讓人忍不住要問，
何時京劇與清官已畫上等號。呼應清官，在現代的劇情上，則安排了一位
果汁大王，他仗著惡霸金主的姿態，完全不尊重夢想家舞團的藝術，於此
又讓人忍不住再問，賣果汁的就不懂不文化嗎 ? (林采韻）
全文連結 http://pareviews.ncafroc.org.tw/?p=716


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 218.168.225.241
→ tuhsiaofu:罵的不夠淋漓盡致                                      10/13 13:57
→ pessoa0926:歡迎投稿噢！                                         10/13 16:19
→ tuhsiaofu:不是藝評人也可以寫嗎？                                10/13 18:01
→ pessoa0926:有投稿評論的單元，針對夢想家也有300字短評徵文。      10/13 18:22
→ pessoa0926:網站有詳細的投稿方式，請見投稿評論。                 10/13 18:23
→ pessoa0926:http://pareviews.ncafroc.org.tw/ 歡迎賜稿。          10/13 18:25
→ home99888:突然覺得那幾個問號都很有呼巴掌的力道......            10/14 00:00
→ tuhsiaofu:呂柏伸在他的臉書發言了，可以去瞧瞧                    10/14 09:43

【推文至plurk】