2012年1月18日 星期三

Re: [新聞] 大S「歌藝論」挺馬 網友諷無知

 作者  dudu5566 (仁甫哥超MAN!!!)                              看板  Gossiping 
 標題  Re: [新聞] 大S「歌藝論」挺馬 網友諷無知                                
 時間  Mon Jan 16 23:45:54 2012                                               

※ 引述《Mews (Common People)》之銘言:
http://tinyurl.com/6nob7ef
: 馬英九順利連任,圈內不少挺藍藝人欣喜若狂,大S在投票前,在微博比出「2」的手勢,
: 拼命催票,還把3組總統候選人比喻成發片藝人,她形容蔡英文是天生的歌手,但訓練不
: 夠就發片,優勢在於新鮮;馬英九則是經過後天努力,歌藝雖然不夠完美,但足於得到獎
: 項鼓勵;而宋楚瑜屢戰屢敗,還有待加強,這些言論被立場不同的網友諷刺,說她自曝其
: 短顯露無知。
: 在鏡頭前刻意比出「耶」的手勢,大S和姐妹淘表態挺馬不言可喻,並留言以發片歌手形容
: 3組總統候選人,她說「2號天生歌藝超群,經過努力學習出了唱片,雖然不夠完美,但足
: 以得到各項大獎」,又評蔡英文,讚美她天生會唱歌,但沒經過訓練就出片,優勢在於新
: 鮮,更形容宋楚瑜屢戰屢敗,歌藝有待加強,大S這樣的比喻沒憑沒據。
: 引來不少立場不同的支持者抗議,根本是鬼話連篇,S媽緊急緩頰,女兒只是關心國家大事
: ,沒有惡意。廣告內容:「在世間最混亂、最不安的時候,你們永遠是最可靠、堅定,而
: 且溫暖的守護者。」
: 蔡英文敗選,讓不少支持者心都碎了,曾經免費幫蔡英文拍廣告的導演吳念真,在網路上
: 抒發失落心情,吳導演把結果看的清淡,他鼓勵選民盡量宣洩情緒,但該過的日子還是要
: 過,一切又會回到正常軌道。
: 而正忙著電影宣傳的吳朋奉,也不忘關心大選,挺綠的他對於結果難掩失望,認為自己不
: 懂台灣人,失落心情溢於言表,藝人關注選情,大選過後兩樣情。

我覺得應該要這樣比喻

1號歌手:歌聲具有特色,形象清新,但唱片公司前任老闆賣過黑心唱片,讓消費者心理有
        陰影,加上媒體資源缺乏,導致雖有實力但終究成為一片歌手。

2號歌手:歌聲平庸,但長得夠帥,所屬唱片公司有錢,媒體也不斷幫忙炒作,因此連拿了
        八年銷售排行榜冠軍

3號歌手:曾經在10幾年前是叱咤台灣的實力派歌手,但年紀已大,雖有實力但曲風已不被
        現代所接受,因此硬要發片的結果是銷售量悽慘


五樓請給分

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 61.58.172.114
推 twic:3號                                                        01/16 23:46
推 helpiou:中肯                                                    01/16 23:46
推 meow0727:支持4號 5566                                           01/16 23:46
推 rriver:支持 5566                                                01/16 23:46
→ bobobola:比喻不錯                                               01/16 23:47
推 rex:還蠻中肯的啊 XDD                                            01/16 23:47
推 amber419:中肯                                                   01/16 23:48
推 modjo:推                                                        01/16 23:48
推 rxcx:中肯推                                                     01/16 23:48
推 kurtsgm:中肯                                                    01/16 23:49
推 beconfident:非常中墾                                            01/16 23:49
→ kaky:1號只有去試錄好嗎連EP都出不來......只有自家錄的試唱帶      01/16 23:49
推 kickmeout:2012最中肯                                            01/16 23:49
推 urban:有中肯                                                    01/16 23:50
→ kickmeout:二號應該再加上買榜                                    01/16 23:50
推 NNPSBK:中肯56                                                   01/16 23:50
→ kaky:2,3號才是有出過片的暢銷歌手只是一個已經過氣了              01/16 23:50
→ NiceGuyOrz:加油 好嗎                                            01/16 23:51
推 jennyperi:中肯                                                  01/16 23:51
推 clintvivA:56不能亡                                              01/16 23:51
推 kicoking:水                                                     01/16 23:51
推 BIGETC:還不錯                                                   01/16 23:52
推 TIGER228:好貼切                                                 01/16 23:52
推 Kamelie:                                                        01/16 23:52
→ troylun:外加2號買榜...XDDDD                                     01/16 23:53
推 DarkKnight:所以2號是不是西洋歌手............                    01/16 23:53
推 MRsoso:若要這樣比喻我認為3號是有做音樂的理想 但不廣為大眾接受   01/16 23:53
推 qscxz:不錯唷 給你個贊                                           01/16 23:53
→ yboa:56比S有想法多了                                            01/16 23:53
推 JamieWu:中肯!                                                  01/16 23:54
→ white75724:1號有實力 實力在哪? 一個兩岸問題都吱吱嗚嗚了         01/16 23:55
推 danish:無知又如何?有沒有FU夠不夠無知,還不是潮到掉渣           01/16 23:57
推 u70098:買榜 哈哈                                                01/16 23:57
→ linchung:你從哪邊知道1號歌聲動聽,技巧十足了?                   01/16 23:57
推 sediments:中肯                                                  01/16 23:57
推 TruMadDeeply:優文 能不推嗎?                                     01/16 23:57
推 peter3561:還不賴                                                01/16 23:58
→ pppeeeppp:3號也有3號的問題阿... 過了氣 但也洗了形象~            01/16 23:59
→ Ricrollp:23中肯  1不認同                                        01/16 23:59
→ pppeeeppp:2號最中肯阿~ 歌聲不只平庸好嗎... 妹妹揹著洋娃娃!!!!   01/17 00:00
推 ckbaboon:2樓買榜 三張抱抱 五張拍照                              01/17 00:01
推 purple909:中肯                                                  01/17 00:02
推 Zeroyeu:中肯!                                                   01/17 00:04
推 chungyiju:                                                      01/17 00:04
→ cairns:4號~不發片也可以佔版面~遠勝裝熟魔人                      01/17 00:07
推 SUBE:推                                                         01/17 00:08
推 noname112:2號就是偶像派嘛 沒實力有長相就夠了                    01/17 00:09
推 KingKingCold:你比大S專業多了XD                                  01/17 00:09
推 aye:專業!給推                                                  01/17 00:11
推 bestrick:中肯XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD                                   01/17 00:11
推 pietoro:應該說一號聲音不錯,具有潛力,但唱的歌沒啥內容不動聽      01/17 00:14
推 Venesa:沒啥內容?連對岸的學者都說小英的路線是務實的              01/17 00:15
推 rademiel:貼切                                                   01/17 00:15
→ Venesa:只是人民對民進黨有疑慮>>>這是民進黨要檢討的              01/17 00:15
推 Miralles:推二號三號評論                                         01/17 00:16
→ gracy100:中肯!!!!!!!!!!本日最中肯~~                 01/17 00:17
※ 編輯: dudu5566        來自: 61.58.172.114        (01/17 00:19)
噓 s9899653:二號.. 我宿舍左前方的回收廠撿一堆他們的文宣 浪費資源   01/17 00:22
推 leemt:超中肯                                                    01/17 00:23
推 cindy790521:專業                                                01/17 00:25
推 roader28:中肯                                                   01/17 00:26
推 Beunique:專業                                                   01/17 00:32
推 esho:中肯 妳是國輪老師還是山倪老師                              01/17 00:36
推 flyingfishy:這才對 叫大s那沒腦的學一學                          01/17 00:58
推 victorshu:不錯                                                  01/17 01:00
→ kevin0733:3號真的是實力派唱將  就像蘇芮  但是現在沒多少人喜歡   01/17 01:15
推 cowbay1000:2號根本就是當年的5566                                01/17 01:16
推 itoh:中肯                                                       01/17 01:25
推 HAT911:本年最中肯                                               01/17 01:54
推 heuer:推                                                        01/17 01:55
推 mjnaoki:幹 這才中肯啊 超專業                                    01/17 02:28
推 fago:你知道太多了XDDDDDDDDDD                                    01/17 02:42
推 Bluebear:XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD                                   01/17 02:43
推 jackloutter:XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD                                    01/17 02:58
推 royalboy:要是當初這樣說肯定反應又不一樣了XDD                    01/17 03:39
推 zincs:評論得不錯!2號買榜XDDD                                    01/17 05:34
推 trtc:對嘛 當初要是大S寫這樣 會被批嗎?                          01/17 07:28
※ hatako:轉錄至某隱形看板                                         01/17 07:34
推 hsien1105:中肯 有腦和無腦的差異被你點出來了                     01/17 08:22
推 sizumaru:中肯                                                   01/17 08:44
推 oue:這真中肯!XD                                                 01/17 08:51
推 assunny1012:很貼切的歌手簡介~                                   01/17 09:05
推 yoyoyo916:滿分                                                  01/17 09:42
推 dalepp:XDD                                                      01/17 10:36
推 momoko51244:中肯                                                01/17 11:04
推 Simakui:中肯~                                                   01/17 12:28
推 amida:推!大S連比喻都比的的不知所云,自曝其短                     01/17 13:20
推 guestcyc:除了一片歌手比喻不恰當之外 其他滿分 小英會堅持下去的   01/17 13:43
推 Bettymeimei:中肯                                                01/17 15:43
推 undeader:GOOD                                                   01/17 16:51